Capturing and Delivering Competitive Advantage in the Japan to Europe and Europe to Japan Air Cargo Markets: The Case of the ANA Cargo and Lufthansa Cargo A.G. Strategic Joint Venture


  • Glenn Baxter Suan Dusit University



air cargo, ANA Cargo, case study, competitive advantage, joint venture, Lufthansa Cargo, Porter’s Five Forces Model


This paper presents a case study of the ANA Cargo and Lufthansa Cargo strategic joint venture, the global air cargo industry’s first strategic joint venture between two of the world’s major air cargo-carrying airlines. The data gathered for the study was examined by document analysis. The strategic analysis of the joint venture was underpinned by the use of Porter’s Five Forces Model. The study found that the joint venture has provided synergistic benefits to both partners and has allowed the partners to access new markets and to participate in the evolution of the air cargo industry. The joint venture has also enabled both joint venture partners to enhance their competitive position in the Europe to Japan and Japan to Europe air cargo markets through strengthened service offerings and has provided the partners with increased cargo capacities, a larger route network, and greater frequencies within their own route networks. A limitation of the study was that ANA Cargo and Lufthansa Cargo revenues, or freight traffic data was not available. It was, therefore, not possible to analyse the business performance of the joint venture.

Author Biography

Glenn Baxter, Suan Dusit University

Associate Research Fellow


Peter Conway. Forced marriages. Airline Business, 15, 54–58, 1999.

Peter Frampton. Where is air cargo heading? Insight, 5, 22–27, 1997.

Peter S. Morrell and Thomas Klein. Moving boxes by air: The economics of international cargo. 2nd ed. Routledge, Abingdon, UK, 2019. ISBN 9781138745490

Anming Zhang, George W.L. Hui, Lawrence C. Leung, and Waiman Cheung. Air cargo in mainland China and Hong Kong. Routledge, Abingdon, UK, 2017. ISBN 13: 97807546421695.

Geloso Grosso, Massimo, and Ben Shepherd. Liberalising Air Cargo Services in APEC, Working Paper October 2009. URL [Online].

Anming Zhang, Chunmei Lang, Y.V. Hui and Lawrence Leung. Intermodal alliance and rivalry of transport chains: The air cargo market. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review,.43(3), 234-246, 2007.

Peter Grönlund and Robert Skoog. Drivers of alliance formation in the air cargo business. In Werner Delfmann, Herbert Baum, Stefan Auerbach and Sacha Albers, editors, Strategic management in the aviation industry, chapter 20, pages 473-487. Routledge, Abingdon, UK, 2016. ISBN 13: 978-0754645672

All Nippon Airways. ANA and Lufthansa Cargo Obtain Antitrust Immunity for Japan-Europe Joint Venture Wider Range of Service Options by Mutual Collaboration Benefit Customers, Media Release 03 September 2014. URL [Online].

André de Almeida. International joint ventures – Brazil. In Darrell Prescott and Salli A. Swartz, editors, Joint Ventures in the international arena, 2nd ed, chapter 6, pages 145-160. ABA Publishing, Chicago, IL, 2010. ISBN 9781590311356

Shane A. Johnson and Mark B. Houston. A rexamination of the motives and gains in joint ventures. The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 35(1): 67-85, 2000.

A. Cemal Ekin and Thomas R. King. A struggling international partnership: TNK-BP joint venture. International Journal of Strategic Business Alliances, 1(1), 89–106, 2009.

Zenichi Shishido, Munetaka Fukuda and Masato Umetani. Joint venture strategies: design, bargaining, and the law, Edward Elgar Publishing: Cheltenham, UK, 2015. ISBN 978-1783475032

Glenn Baxter and Panarat Srisaeng. Cooperating to compete in the global air cargo industry: The case of the DHL Express and Lufthansa Cargo A.G. joint venture airline ‘AeroLogic’. Infrastructures, 3(1), 7, 2018.

Charles W. L. Hill, Melissa A. Schilling, Gareth R. Jones. Strategic management: theory: an integrated approach. 12th ed. Cengage Learning: Stamford, CT, 2015. ISBN 978-1305502338

Luís Morais. Joint ventures and EU competition law. Hart Publishing: Oxford, UK, 2013. ISBN 978-1841137933

Azhar Kazmi. Strategic management and business policy. 3rd ed. Tata-McGraw Hill Publishing: New Delhi, India, 2008. ISBN 13: 978-0-07-026362-8

Daniel F Spulber. Economics and management of competitive strategy. World Scientific Publishing: Singapore, 2009. ISBN 978-9812838469

Yanni Yan. International joint ventures in China: ownership, control and performance. Macmillan Press: London, UK, 2000. ISBN 978-0312223014

Ian Hewitt, L. Joint ventures, 3rd ed. Sweet & Maxwell: London, UK, 2005. ISBN 978-0421739802

Jeffrey S. Harrison. Alternative to merger-Joint ventures and other strategies. Long Range Planning, 20(6), 78–83, 1987.

Aimin Yan and Yadong Luo. International joint ventures: theory and practice. Routledge: Abingdon, UK, 2015. ISBN 13: 978-0765604743

Paul W. Beamish and Nathaniel C. Lupton. Managing joint ventures. Academy of Management Perspectives, 23(2), 75–94, 2009.

Sal Kukalis and Mark Jungemann. Strategic planning for a joint venture. Long Range Planning, 28(3), 4–5, 46-57, 1995.

Robert D. Hisrich, Mathew J Manimala, Michael P. Peters; Dean A. Shepherd. Entrepreneurship, 9th ed.; McGraw-Hill Education: New Delhi, India, 2012. ISBN 13-978-392-0538-6

Aileen Chang. Critical success factors for joint ventures. URL [Online].

Robert D. Hisrich, Michael P. Peters, Dean A. Shepherd. Entrepreneurship, 6th ed. McGraw-Hill Professional, New York, N.Y, 2005. ISBN 9780071259521

Phil Harris and Frank McDonald. European business and marketing, 2nd ed. SAGE Publications Ltd, London, UK, 2004. ISBN 0761966056

Levent Altinay, Alexandros Paraskevas, SooCheong (Shawn) Jang. Planning research in hospitality and tourism, 2nd ed. Routledge, Abingdon, UK, 2016. ISBN 13: 978-1138852167

Keith W. Glaister, Rumy Husan, Peter J. Buckley. Strategic business alliances: an examination of the core dimensions. Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham, UK, 2004. ISBN 9781843761778

Ursula. F. Ott. International joint ventures: an interplay of cooperative and noncooperative games under incomplete information. Palgrave-Macmillan, Basingstoke, UK, 2006. ISBN 978-0-230-62546-4

Hao Ma. Creation and preemption for competitive advantage. Management. Decision, 37(3), 259-267, 1999.

Will Kenton, W. Competitive advantage. URL [Online].

Airlines International. Strategizing for success. URL [Online].

Delta Air Lines. Delta and Korean Air to launch world-class joint venture partnership. URL [Online].

Korean Air. A joint venture between Korean Air and Delta Air Lines. URL [Online].

Cargo Airports & Airline Services. United Airlines and Lufthansa Cargo announce cargo joint venture agreement. URL: [Online].

KLM Royal Dutch Airlines. China Southern Airlines Cargo and Air France KLM Martinair Cargo intensify strategic cooperation, News Release 17 October 2017. URL [Online].

Nina Chamlou. Cainiao + Emirates. URL [Online].

Air Cargo World. Turkish + PAL Air + ZTO Express. URL [Online].

Air Cargo News. Turkish Airlines creates cargo unit for integrator joint venture with ZTO and PAL Air. URL [Online].

Air Cargo News. Azul and Correios’ E-Commerce joint venture gains anti-trust approval in Brazil. URL [Online].

Gbenga Oduntan. Sovereignty and jurisdiction in airspace and outer space: legal criteria for spatial delimitation. Routledge, Abingdon, UK, 2012. ISBN 9780415562126

Tae Hoon Oum and Chunyan Yu. Winning airlines: productivity and cost competitiveness of the world’s major airlines, Transportation, Research, Economics and Policy, Volume 6; Kluwer Academic Publishers, Norwell, MA, 2001. ISBN 978-0-7923-8010-8

Zhi. H. Wang and Michael Evans. The impact of market liberalization on the formation of airline alliances. Journal of Air Transportation, 7(2), 25–52, 2002.

Rigas Doganis. The airline business, 2nd ed. Routledge, Abingdon, UK, 2005. ISBN 9780415346153

Volodymyr Bilotkach, V. European market: present and future. In Matthias Finger and Kenneth Button, editors, Air transport liberalization: a critical assessment. Chapter 8, pages 138-155. Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham, UK, 2017. ISBN 978 1 78643 185 1

Temel Caner Ustaömer, Vildan Durmaz and Zheng Lei. The effect of joint ventures on airline competition: The case of American airlines, British airways and Iberia joint business. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, (210), 430–439, 2015.

Qatar Airways. Qatar Airways announces its acquisition of 9.61% of Cathay Pacific, News Release 6 November 2017. URL [Online] .

Stephen W. Wang. Do global airline alliances influence the passenger’s purchase decision? Journal of Air Transport Management, 37, 53–59, 2014.

Aaron B. Scholz. Network structures of cargo airlines: an empirical and modelling approach. KIT Scientific Publishing, Karlsruhe, Germany, 2012. ISBN 9783866447967

Conway, P.; Kingsley-Jones, M. New era for Lufthansa-DHL. Airline Business 2008, 24(3), 25.

Stephen Holloway. Straight and level: practical airline economics, 3rd ed. Routledge, Abingdon, UK, 2016. ISBN 978-0754672586

Air Cargo World. Cargo alliances await technology. URL [Online]

Peter Conway. Selective customers. Airline Business 2003, 19(3), 62–64.

Peter Conway. Team work. Airline Business 2004, 20(11, 58–59.

Anna Lena Bischoff. Porters five forces. innovation through business, engineering; CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform, Scotts Valley, CA, US, 2017. ISBN 978-3668209091

John F. Rice. Adaption of Porter’s Five Forces Model to risk management. URL [Online].

Michael E. Porter. How competitive forces shape strategy? In Michael E. Porter and Cynthia A. Montgomery, editors, Strategy: seeking and securing competitive advantage, chapter 2, pages 11-25. Harvard Business School Publishing: Boston, MA, 1991. ISBN 9780875842431

Figen Uçmak and Cansu Arslan. The impact of competition conditions on new market entrants in Istanbul Hotel Industry: An analyse by using five forces of competitive position model of M. Porter. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 58, 1037-1046, 2012.

Süleyman Barutçu and Mustafa Zihni Tunca. The impacts of E-SCM on the E-tailing industry: An analysis from Porter's Five Force perspectives. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 58, 1047-1056, 2012.

C. Appa Rao, B. Parvathiswara Rao and K Sivaramakrishna. Strategic management and business policy. Excel Books, New Delhi, India, 2008. ISBN 9788174466686

John W. Creswell. Qualitative inquiry and research design: choosing among five approaches. SAGE Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA, 2007. ISBN 978-1412995306

Gina Grandy. Instrumental case study. In Albert J. Mills, Gabrielle Durepos and Elden Wiebe, editors, Encyclopedia of case study research, volume 1, pages 473-475. SAGE Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA, 2010. ISBN 9781412956703

Robert. E. Stake. The art of case study research. SAGE Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA, 1995. ISBN 0803957661

Tarnue Johnson. A critical examination of Firestone's operations in Liberia: A case study approach. Author House, Bloomington, IN, 2010. ISBN 978-1452089447

Alan Bryman. A. Social research methods, 4th ed. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK, 2012. ISBN 978-0199588053

Hans Doorewaard. Conceptional model: Causal model study. In Albert J. Mills, Gabrielle Durepos and Elden Wiebe, editors, Encyclopedia of case study research, volume 1, pages 202-203. SAGE Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA, 2010. ISBN 9781412956703

Abd Rahman Abdul Rahim and Mohd Shariff Nabi Baksh. Case study method for product development in engineer-to-order organisations. Work Study, 52(1), 25-36, 2003.

Robert K. Yin. Case study research and applications, 6th ed. SAGE Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA, 2017. ISBN 978-1506336169

Glenn Baxter and Panarat Srisaeng. The strategic deployment of the Airbus A350-900XWB aircraft in a full-service network carrier route network: The case of Singapore Airlines. Infrastructures, 3(3), 25, 2018.

Briony J. Oates. Researching information systems and computing. SAGE Publications, London, UK, 2006. ISBN 978-1412902243

Helen Simons. Case study research in practice. SAGE Publications, London, UK, 2009. ISBN 978-0761964247

Lynn Chester. A rėgulationist analysis of an industry sector using mixed research methods. In The Late Frederic S. Lee and Bruce Cronin, editors, Handbook of research methods and applications in heterodox economics, chapter 29, pages 569-590. Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham, UK, 2016. ISBN 978-1782548454

John Scott. A matter of record: documentary sources in social research. Polity Press, Cambridge, UK, 1990. ISBN 0745600301

John Scott and Gordon Marshall. A dictionary of sociology, 3rd ed. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK, 2009. ISBN 9780199533008

James Fulcher and John Scott. Sociology, 4th ed. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK, 2011.ISBN 9780199563753

Kristin Shrader-Frechette and Earl D. McCoy. Community ecology, population biology, and the method of case studies. In David R. Keller and Frank B. Golley, editors. The philosophy of ecology: from science to synthesis, pages 153-169. University of Georgia Press, Athens, Greece, 2000. ISBN 978-0820322209

Berta van Schoor. Fighting corruption collectively: how successful are sector-specific coordinated governance initiatives in curbing corruption. Springer VS, Wiesbaden, Germany, 2017. ISBN 978-3-658-17837-6

Zina O'Leary. The essential guide to doing research. SAGE Publications, London, UK, 2004. ISBN 978-0761941989

Pamela L. Morris. Triangulation. In Mike Allen, editor, The SAGE encyclopedia of communication research methods; pages 1781-1783. SAGE Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA, 2017. ISBN 978-1483381435

William Green and Gordon Swanborough. The observer’s world airlines and airliners directory. Frederick Warne & Co Ltd, London, UK, 1975. ISBN 0723215472

Christopher Chant. Airlines of the world. Tiger Books International, London, UK, 1997. ISBN 1855019124

All Nippon Airways. ANA announces flight schedule and sales start date for Airbus A380 FLYING HONU, Media Release 26 December 2018. URL

ANA Holdings Inc. fact book 2018. URL

Heike Bruch and Thomas Sattelberger. The turnaround at Lufthansa: Learning from the change process. Journal of Change Management 1(4), 344–363, 2000.

Lufthansa Cargo A.G. About us. URL

Lufthansa Cargo A.G. Facts and figures. URL

Lufthansa Cargo A.G. The key points in our logistic network: stations, hubs and more. URL

Thomas L. Gallagher. Lufthansa, Austrian Airlines create joint cargo unit. Journal of Commerce Online, 27 May 2010. URL

Lufthansa Group A.G. Annual report 2017. URL

Lufthansa Cargo. ANA and Lufthansa Cargo obtain antitrust immunity for Japan-Europe joint venture. URL

Air Cargo World. ANA, Lufthansa Cargo launch Japan-Europe joint venture. URL

Bruce Barnard. Lufthansa Cargo-ANA joint venture takes off. URL

Sam Jermy. All Nippon and Lufthansa Cargo successfully launch air cargo joint venture. URL

Lufthansa Cargo. Joint venture between Lufthansa Cargo and ANA Cargo to cover Europe to Japan as of August. URL

Payload Asia. ANA, Lufthansa expand cargo joint network in Japan. Payload Asia, 32(1), 3-4, 2016.

Lufthansa Cargo. Lufthansa Cargo and ANA extend joint venture, Media Release 28 June 2016. URL

Bruce Barnard. Lufthansa Cargo extends All Nippon Airways joint venture. URL

Marc Oedekoven. Air cargo management. In Andreas Wald, Christoph Fay and Ronald Gleich, editors, Introduction to aviation management, chapter 13, pages 310-327. LIT Verlag: Münster, Germany, 2010. ISBN 9783643906939

Glenn S. Baxter and Nicholas S. Bardell. Can the renewed interest in ultra-long-range passenger flights be satisfied by the current generation of civil aircraft? Aviation, 21(2), 42–54, 2017.

John J. Coyle, Robert A. Novack, Brian Gibson and Edward J. Bardi. Transportation: a supply chain perspective, 7th ed. South-Western Cengage Learning: Mason, OH, 2011. ISBN 13:9780324789195

Boeing Commercial Airplanes. 747-400 Airplane characteristics for airport planning, Document Number D6-58326-1. URL

Boeing Commercial Airplanes. 747-8 airplane characteristics for airport planning, Document Number D6-58326-3. URL

Boeing Commercial Airplanes. 777-200LR/-300ER/-freighter airplane characteristics for airport planning, Document Number D6-58329-2. URL

Andrei Panibratov. Russian multinationals: from regional supremacy to global lead; Routledge: Abingdon, UK, 2012. ISBN 978-0415615884

Andreas Knorr and Andreas Arndt. Most low-cost airlines fail(ed): Why did Southwest Airlines prosper? In Peter Forsyth, David W. Gillen, Otto G. Mayer and Hans-Martin Niemeier, editors, Competition versus predation in aviation markets: a survey of experience in North America, Europe and Australia, chapter 8, pages 145-172. Routledge, Abingdon, UK, 2018. ISBN 978-0754641957

Triant G. Flouris and Sharon L. Oswald. Designing and executing strategy in aviation management. Ashgate Publishing, Aldershot, UK, 2006. ISBN 9780754636182

Stephen Shaw. Airline marketing and management, 7th ed. Ashgate Publishing, Farnham, UK, 2011. ISBN 9781409401490

P.S. Senguttuvan. Principles of airport economics. Excel Books, New Delhi, India, 2007. ISBN 8174465235

Jaap Bouwer, Dominic Maxwell, and Steve Saxon. Gridlock on the ground: how airlines can respond to airport congestion. URL

Claus Ulrich. Congestion and slot allocation. URL

Michael A. Hitt, R. Duane Ireland, Robert E. Hoskisson. Strategic management: concepts and cases: competitiveness and globalization, 11th ed. Cengage Learning, Stamford, CT, 2015. ISBN 9781285425184

Boeing Commercial Airplanes. Lufthansa Group. URL

Adrian Schofield, A. Waiting game. Aviation Week and Space Technology, 175(8), 35-36, 2013.

Paul W. Forster and Amelia A. Regan. Electronic Integration in the air cargo industry: An information processing model of on-time performance. Transportation. Journal, 40(4), 46–61, 2001.

Peter Conway. Dominant force. Airline Business, 21(11), 52–54, 2005.

Michael W. Tretheway and Robert J. Andriulaitis, R.J. Airport competition for freight. In Peter Forsyth, David Gillen, Jurgen Muller and Hans-Martin Niemeier, editors, Airport competition: the European experience, chapter 10, pages 137-150. Routledge, Abingdon, UK, 2016.

Cottrill, K. High hopes. Traffic World, 256, 28–33, 1998.

Lufthansa Cargo. Our partner program. URL

Hendrik Lemke. Strategic market expansions in the rail freight sector: DB Schenker rail’s acquisition of PCC rail in Poland. Anchor Academic Publishing, Hamburg, Germany, 2015. ISBN 9783954892501

The Economist. New rail routes between China and Europe will change trade patterns. URL

All Nippon Airways. ANA and Lufthansa Cargo obtain antitrust immunity for Japan-Europe joint venture: wider range of service options by mutual collaboration benefit customers. URL

Phil Hastings. LH In talks with new joint venture partners, Asia Cargo News, 27 April 2015. URL

Jan Walulik. Progressive commercialization of airline governance culture. Routledge, Abingdon, UK, 2017. ISBN 978-1138654990

Sky King. Front foot for ANA Cargo. URL






Review Articles